Eddies Pizza

Discover delicious, affordable pizza at Eddies Pizza in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY. Enjoy handcrafted pies, garlic knots, stuffed, Sicilian slices, meatballs, and spaghetti in a welcoming local spot. Call +1 631-676-4622!

Welcome to Eddies Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Eddies Pizza
Eddies Pizza
Eddies Pizza
Eddies Pizza

Eddies Pizza stands out in Lake Ronkonkoma for its delicious pies and welcoming atmosphere. Located at 163 Ronkonkoma Ave, this pizza haven captures the hearts—and appetites—of local diners. The charming decor and friendly staff create an inviting space for families and friends to gather and enjoy mouthwatering meals. From the moment you step in, the smell of fresh pizza and garlic knots envelops you, setting the tone for a satisfying experience.

The menu features a diverse range of options, from classic Sicilian slices to hearty meatballs, ensuring every visit holds something new. Prices are reasonable, making it the go-to spot for both lunch and dinner, especially on busy Fridays when the place hums with excitement.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

163 Ronkonkoma Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779, United States

Phone

+1 631-676-4622

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Eddies Pizza
Eddies Pizza
Eddies Pizza
Eddies Pizza

Eddies Pizza is not just a restaurant; it's a community hub in Lake Ronkonkoma. Known for its unbeatable combination of quality and affordability, Eddies has become a staple for locals. Established years ago, this pizzeria has evolved to meet the tastes of its loyal clientele while sticking to the tried-and-true recipes that won their hearts from the start. Customers often flock here because of their mouthwatering garlic knots, stuffed Sicilian pizza, and rich spaghetti dishes that reflect authentic Italian cuisine.

The upbeat atmosphere encourages a sense of community, with families and friends constantly sharing laughter and delicious meals.

The staff at Eddies Pizza thrive on creating memorable experiences. On busy nights—especially Fridays when every table is filled—the energy is contagious. Everyone shares the excitement, whether it's the regulars or newcomers who are tasting the iconic pies for the first time.

Peak times reveal how beloved this spot is; on Mondays, lunchtime has a cozy feel especially with the average number of diners around 33.3%. But Friday nights? That’s the pinnacle of activity—filling every inch of the restaurant with laughing families and clinking plates.

Eddies also responds to customer feedback, continually adapting its specials, such as the monthly rotation of vegetarian and seafood dishes.

Offering a variety of options helps to maintain engagement and attracts even the most discerning food lovers. With an expanding menu and dedicated service, it remains the place to receive both casual slices and hearty Italian meals. Whether a lunchtime escape or a night out with friends, Eddies Pizza caters to every need, wrapping guests in a warm, welcoming embrace every time.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-9 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Eddies Pizza boasts an extensive menu that caters to every craving. Enjoy specialties like their Wednesday Special, where a delightful meal averages around $23, perfect for a midweek treat. For those seeking something unique, the Vegetable Specialty Pie at $36 delivers big on flavor and presentation. Each dish varies in sizes, with salads priced around $12.80, offering something fresh to accompany your meal.

Notable favorites include stuffed garlic knots, a true crowd-pleaser, and Italian entrees such as Chicken Parmigiana and Eggplant Parmigiana, all priced around $16.25.

Eddies ensures there's a delectable option for everyone, whether it's a quick slice or a sit-down feast with friends. The inviting layout is perfect for families, with seating that accommodates both small and large groups.

Eddies Pizza

The exterior of Eddies Pizza is inviting, with its vibrant signage that beckons pizza lovers in from Ronkonkoma Avenue. The cheerful colors and well-kept surroundings highlight the restaurant’s commitment to hospitality. Seating outside during pleasant days allows diners to soak up the local vibe while enjoying their favorite slices. The overall vibe? It's relaxed yet buzzing with excitement, reflecting the fun atmosphere that draws in the locals.

The communal spirit truly shines here, as you’ll often find neighbors chatting while waiting for their orders, creating a lively and friendly community gathering spot. No matter the time of day, Eddies Pizza fosters connections among diners.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

They were amazing! I called in the morning and asked if they could make a pizza shaped like the number 4 for my sons birthday. I didn't plan ahead and did it that day. They made it and were so sweet about it. The pizza was good. I had no complaints, they even asked if I wanted them to trim the edges to make it perfect. Really happy about the customer service!

M
Madeline W.

The employees are amazing. This food is so delicious and so fresh and always ready on time. The best I've had so far.

K
Kimathi M.

This is our go to pizza. Always fresh. Great wings. Prices are reasonable. Friendly staff.

d
d t.

This place has the most amazing pinwheels. I love the ham and cheese! On a whim I ordered spaghetti and clam sauce. My husband commented on how good it looked as he took it out of the bag. When I sat down to eat it, it really did look good with the clams arranged nicely on top. Even in take out the presentation counts! And it tasted even better than it looked. It was just a quick last second addition that ended up being the star of our meal. Delicious!!!

s
s m.

Pin wheels were delivered cool, were delicious! Meatball Parm hero was all breading 90% 30 % meat fell apart on hero . Never would order again! Pizza always Good! Delivery quick! This is one of the best Pizza Restaurants in the area. Prices are great! And so are the owners! They have been. Serving the area since before I moved here. In 1987! Stop By...

D
Donna D.

Pizza is always fresh , service fast. My son is picky, and likes their pepperoni a lot. They have generous slice sizes , not like others that are small and paper thin.

S
SOUR-GIRL- 1.